Sugar Creek Real Estate

Sugar Creek Real Estate

Nestled in the heart of Indiana, Sugar Creek is a hidden gem that offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. This picturesque community is renowned for its serene landscapes, friendly atmosphere, and rich history, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a peaceful lifestyle.

One of Sugar Creek’s most appealing features is its stunning natural beauty. The area is dotted with lush parks, scenic trails, and the tranquil Sugar Creek itself, which provides ample opportunities for outdoor activities such as hiking, fishing, and picnicking. The vibrant local flora and fauna create a picturesque backdrop for residents and visitors alike, making it a haven for nature enthusiasts.

In addition to its natural allure, Sugar Creek boasts a strong sense of community. The town is known for its welcoming residents, who take pride in fostering a friendly environment. Local events, festivals, and farmers' markets bring neighbors together, creating a tight-knit atmosphere that makes everyone feel at home.

Families will appreciate the quality of education available in the area, with well-regarded schools that prioritize student growth and community involvement. Additionally, Sugar Creek’s strategic location provides easy access to larger cities, ensuring that residents can enjoy the tranquility of small-town life while still being just a short drive away from urban amenities.

Whether you’re looking to buy your first home, retire in peace, or find a place to raise a family, Sugar Creek, Indiana, offers a welcoming and enriching environment that truly feels like home. Explore the possibilities of life in this charming community and discover why so many are proud to call Sugar Creek their home.

Newest Listings in Sugar Creek

$399,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
You will Love this Gorgeous Custom 3 Bedroom Home in New Palestine's Popular Neighborhood of Brier Creek. The Home is Perfectly Nestled on a Nice Quiet Street that Just Says, "Welcome Home" as soon as You See It". Beautiful Hardwoods Adorn the Living Area, Kitchen and Breakfast Nook. Kitchen has All SS Appliances, Center Island and Large Walk in Pantry. Enjoy Watching the Birds and Wildlife from your Cozy Sunroom with Numerous Windows for Lots of Natural Lighting. Fenced Backyard is Lovely with Cute Garden Shed and Stunning Landscaping including a Variety of Perennials. Roof and Gutter Guards were replaced in 2021, Siding in 2022 and Deck in 2026.

6553 Lana Court E, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of REMAX ONE.

$265,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
This home will need work but will be a dream home for someone with vision and renovation dollars. Built in 1986, this home offers 2,209 square feet of space that sits on .55 acres in a small neighborhood (No hoa!). The living room provides a welcoming atmosphere, floor to ceiling clearance, centered around a beautiful brick fireplace which will be perfect for gathering and relaxation. With 3 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms (2 bathrooms are en-suite for primary/2nd bedroom), this 1.5-story home offers unique features and endless potential. An attached garage adds convenience and practical storage solutions along with the sheds in the backyard. Roof and siding replaced 4 years ago.

5586 W Beechwood Lane, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Highgarden Real Estate.

$349,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to this beautifully renovated all-brick ranch nestled on just over an acre, where modern updates meet peaceful country living. This move-in-ready 3-bedroom, 2-bath home features an open-concept layout with vaulted ceilings, abundant natural light, and a stunning wood-burning fireplace with insert. The beautifully updated kitchen offers custom cabinetry and a pantry, a striking herringbone tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, and a spacious breakfast bar perfect for gathering. Both bathrooms have been thoughtfully redesigned with custom tile showers and floors, designer vanities, and upscale finishes. Every major component has been updated, including the Roof, HVAC system with all new Ductwork and Vents, Windows, Well Pump and Compressor, Water Softener, Kitchen Appliances, Flooring, Lighting, and Fresh Paint. Enjoy the finished 2-car garage, screened porch, large deck, new concrete walkway, fresh gravel driveway, and spacious yard surrounded by mature trees. This is country living at its finest with ALL the updates already done for you. Please see the attached list of improvements for additional updates and features.

8162 W Fall Road, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Highgarden Real Estate.

$54,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Enjoy the peaceful surrounding of Saint Mary of the Woods Village. This older modular features 3-bedrooms, 2-baths a rather large Livingroom with dining area that is off the kitchen. There are 2 good size decks the front overlooks St Mary's College, back deck is off the dining area.

4002 Keegan Road, West Terre Haute

Listing courtesy of L.J. Michaels, Inc..

$400,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Here is your chance to escape to the country! This 2 bedroom, 1.5 bath Bedford stone ranch offers a full unfinished basement that is bone dry, perfect for finishing. Much of the original character of the home remains preserved. The formal living room offers wood burning fireplace with stone front and built-in bookshelves, original hardwood flooring in great condition for refinishing, and large picture window to enjoy the beauty of the country side. The eat-in kitchen offers knotty pine walls and cabinetry, with retro countertops and tile backsplash still intact. Both bedrooms offer hardwood flooring and nice sized closets. The full bathroom offers a bathtub with shower surround, and updated vanity. There is a powder bath down the hall for guest use. 27x11 sunroom at the rear of the home offers wood stove for use during the cooler months. Oversized 1 car attached garage is fully finished with heating and cooling, could be possible to convert to a 3rd bedroom if needed. The basement has a framed family room space with woodburning fireplace. 30x27 blank space perfect for rec rm. Utility room with sump pit. The home sits on 1.2 acres of ground, with over 1,200sqft of heated detached garage space PLUS 15x11 workshop with electricity on opposite end of the property. Roof new in 2026! Rural living at its finest with no neighbors on any side of the home. Homes like this are hard to come by, don't miss your chance to say goodbye to city living!

3608 N London Road, Fairland

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners.

$670,400
Discover 20.96 acres of tillable farmland in a quiet Thorntown setting. This versatile property offers an ideal opportunity to build your dream home, create a private family compound, or continue agricultural use. Enjoy peaceful country living with convenient access to the LEAP District and surrounding communities-a rare combination of privacy, acreage, and long-term potential.

5501 N 1100 W, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of D.M. Taylor Realty LLC.

$269,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Charming Brick Ranch on Nearly Half an Acre - Minutes from Downtown New Palestine! Welcome home to this beautifully refreshed 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath all-brick ranch nestled on an expansive .46-acre lot just a hop, skip, and a jump from charming downtown New Palestine. You'll enjoy the perfect blend of small-town charm and everyday convenience. Step inside to discover fresh new interior paint, updated laminate flooring and carpeting, creating a bright, clean, move-in-ready atmosphere. A brand-new roof offers added peace of mind. Outside, the nearly half-acre yard provides endless possibilities-whether you envision backyard barbecues, gardening, a play area, or simply relaxing while enjoying the open space. The timeless all-brick exterior delivers lasting curb appeal with low-maintenance durability. Saturday Open House first opportunity to view this beauty August 1, from 2:00-5:00 p.m. *** Seller has never used the fireplace ***

3426 S Leonard Road, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of New Quantum Realty Group.

$195,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to Historic Boggstown! This charming, thoughtfully updated home blends timeless character with modern comfort. Relax on the spacious covered front porch or enjoy the fully fenced yard with mature trees, a storage shed, and plenty of space for gardening, entertaining, or pets. Inside, you'll find a remodeled kitchen (2024) with abundant cabinet storage, newer stainless steel appliances (2024), fresh interior paint (2024), luxury vinyl plank flooring in the primary bedroom (2024), and updated electrical and plumbing completed within the last few years. The reconfigured floor plan features a spacious primary suite, a versatile second bedroom, two mudrooms with exterior access, and a partial basement for additional storage. Located just steps from Boggstown Park with convenient access to I-74, State Road 44, and I-65, this home is approximately 25 minutes from downtown Indianapolis and less than 10 minutes from Horseshoe Indianapolis. Situated in the Triton School District, it offers the perfect blend of small-town charm and commuter convenience. Additional improvements include a new privacy fence (2024), newer oven, range hood, dishwasher, sink, and refrigerator (all 2024). The washer and dryer are included, making this home move-in ready.

6783 W Boggstown Road, Boggstown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$350,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Discover this opportunity at 5037 W Us Highway 52 HWY W in NEW PALESTINE, IN. This charming 1240 square foot single-family residence, built in 1950, offers a unique foundation for your envisioned lifestyle. This inviting single-story home sits on a generous .36 of an acre, providing ample outdoor space for relaxation or recreation. Embrace the potential of this distinctive property and schedule your private showing today. There are endless possibilities with this one. You can live here and run a small business! Possible commercial opportunities. You'll enjoy the floor plan, nice size lot, basement, and big garage just to name a few of it's features. Make sure to see the office attached to the garage with it's own bath. This home use to be a 3 bedroom - said 3rd bedroom was turned into a second full bath and laundry room on the main level. There is laundry in the basement too. Conveniently located and beautiful lot to boot! Two covered porches! See it today!

5037 W Us Highway 52 Highway W, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$189,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
You will love this 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom charming home in a fantastic location in the heart of downtown Thorntown! Inside, you'll find a large living room leading into the spacious eat-in kitchen complete with modern cabinetry updated within the last few years, a gas stove and laundry closet/pantry. Your 2 bedrooms offer plenty of closet space close to the recently remodeled full bathroom. Downstairs, the basement offers plenty of room for extra storage or another space away from the hustle and bustle. Outside, enjoy a full privacy fenced backyard featuring a covered patio, ideal for relaxing or entertaining in any weather, along with a 2 car attached garage with bonus workshop space. You're just minutes from everything that downtown Thorntown has to offer, including the library, park, Big 4 Rail Trail, restaurants, coffee shop and shopping galore! Come see it today!

120 E Plum Street, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indpls Metro N.

$575,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
BIG and SPACIOUS!!! Welcome home to over 3,600 square feet of thoughtfully designed living in sought-after Schildmeier Village. This updated traditional home features 4 bedrooms, including a main-level primary suite, cathedral ceilings, dedicated office, bonus room, updated kitchen with hard-surface countertops and stainless steel appliances, UPGRADED luxury vinyl plank flooring, plus a beautiful all-season sunroom. Step outside to your private backyard paradise featuring a heated in-ground saltwater pool with a new liner & pump. Privacy fence, patio & mature shade trees complete the backyard. This home offers the perfect combination of elegance, functionality, and outdoor living. Quick Commute to I-465 & I-70. New Palestine "4" Star Schools!

3897 S Woodfield Drive S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of New Quantum Realty Group.

$399,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Like NEW! This beautiful home features 4 spacious bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and a functional floor plan designed for both privacy and togetherness. The main level offers a distinct formal living room set apart from the rest of the home, providing an ideal quiet space for entertaining or relaxing. Toward the back, you will find a light-filled, open-concept family room, dining area, and kitchen. The chef-inspired kitchen boasts a large island, crisp white cabinets, quality appliances, and a generously sized walk-in pantry. Everyday convenience is built into the main floor with a mud room, half bath, and dedicated laundry room leading directly to the attached 3-car garage. Upstairs, escape to the expansive primary bedroom suite complete with a private ensuite bath featuring a double vanity, separate shower, and impressive walk-in closet, alongside three additional bedrooms and a full bath. Step outside to enjoy quiet evenings on the patio overlooking a large, tree-lined backyard set within the desirable Grants Corner community, where you will love access to the on-site park, playground, and scenic walking trails.

7216 Jackson Drive, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of Redfin Corporation.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative