Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

Welcome to Sugar Creek, Indiana – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Midwest! Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Sugar Creek offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and modern convenience. With lush green parks, scenic walking trails, and a vibrant local culture, it's no wonder that families and individuals alike are drawn to this serene locale.

Sugar Creek is ideally situated just a short drive from larger urban centers, providing residents with easy access to shopping, dining, and entertainment while still enjoying the tranquility of suburban life. The area's rich history and strong sense of community make it a wonderful place to call home. Whether you’re looking to enjoy a peaceful afternoon at the local farmers market or take part in community events, there’s always something happening in Sugar Creek!

If you're in the market for a new home, you're in luck! Sugar Creek boasts a variety of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. From charming single-family houses with spacious yards to modern townhomes, there’s something for everyone. Many homes feature beautiful architectural details, updated amenities, and are located within friendly neighborhoods, perfect for raising a family or enjoying a peaceful retirement.

With its welcoming atmosphere and beautiful surroundings, Sugar Creek is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Explore the homes for sale today and discover the perfect spot for you and your loved ones in this enchanting Indiana community!

Newest Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

4937 W Jamestown Trace, New Palestine
$403,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to this stunning 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom home built in 2023, located in the desirable New Palestine community! Offering modern finishes, spacious living areas, and a thoughtfully designed floor plan, this beautiful home combines comfort, style, and functionality. Step inside to an inviting foyer featuring beautiful luxury vinyl flooring and an elegant staircase. The expansive open concept living room offers abundant natural light, recessed lighting, and plenty of space for entertaining. The spacious kitchen features white cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, generous counter space, a large pantry, and an open layout flowing seamlessly into the dining and living areas. Sliding glass doors provide convenient access to the backyard, perfect for indoor and outdoor entertaining. The main level also features a dedicated office, ideal for working from home, along with a convenient bathroom. Upstairs, retreat to the oversized primary suite featuring a spacious bedroom, private bathroom, and generous walk in closet. Three additional bedrooms, multiple walk in closets, additional bathrooms, and a conveniently located upstairs laundry room provide exceptional functionality and storage. The impressive exterior showcases a beautiful combination of brick, stone, and board and batten siding, complemented by a spacious three car attached garage and expansive concrete driveway. Built in 2023, this home offers the appeal of newer construction without the wait! Enjoy modern living, generous space, and a beautiful setting in New Palestine, Indiana. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, and everyday amenities. Schedule your private showing today!

4937 W Jamestown Trace, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Christopher Jenkins. La Terre Boutique

11650 W 800  N, Colfax
$575,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Experience the beauty of country living in this extensively renovated 1930s home, nestled on 1.66 acres among mature trees and expansive countryside views. Timeless character and craftsmanship are evident throughout, from the original hardwood floors, beautiful woodwork and solid wood doors to the charming built-ins and architectural details. The thoughtfully updated kitchen showcases beautiful cabinetry, granite countertops, vintage-inspired designer appliances, a distinctive furniture-style island and refinished hardwood floors. The spacious dining room with original built-ins is perfect for gathering with family and friends, while the inviting living room features a wood-burning stove and abundant natural light. Two bedrooms on the main level complement a beautifully remodeled full bath featuring an oversized tiled walk-in shower, dual vanities, original tile flooring and a classic clawfoot tub. Upstairs offers three additional bedrooms and a half bath. Extensive improvements go well beyond cosmetics, including all-new electrical wiring and plumbing, 200-amp service, new windows, gutters, chimney improvements, whole-house water filtration and a French drain and sump pump system with battery backup, creating a dry, usable basement. Enjoy morning coffee on the covered porch, afternoons in the garden and evenings relaxing in the hot tub on the spacious deck. A ramp provides convenient access to the home. The incredible traditional red barn offers tremendous versatility with 100-amp electrical service, a heated garage/workshop with propane heat and a wood-burning stove, concrete flooring and expansive additional space for parking, equipment, storage, hobbies or a potential home office. Whether you envision a hobby farm, a place to pursue your passions or simply a retreat from the hustle and bustle, this is a special opportunity to embrace the country lifestyle without sacrificing modern comforts. An additional 3.34 wooded acres are available for purchase separately.

11650 W 800 N, Colfax

Listing courtesy of Stephen Clark. Compass Indiana, LLC

3874 White Willow Way, New Palestine
$455,995
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Photos are of the same floor plan; finishes and features may vary. This Silverthorne home in the Willow Ridge community offers the opportunity to enjoy new construction with anticipated completion in early February 2027, backed by a builder warranty and thoughtfully designed for comfortable single-level living. The popular Eisenhower floor plan seamlessly connects the kitchen, nook, and great room, creating an inviting space for both everyday living and entertaining. The well-appointed kitchen includes a center island and overlooks the main living areas, while the spacious design provides a connected and functional flow throughout the home. A full daylight basement offers exceptional storage potential and opportunities for future living space. The private primary suite serves as a relaxing retreat with a walk-in closet and en-suite bath featuring a double-bowl vanity and tiled shower with semi-frameless glass door. Two additional bedrooms and a full hall bath provide comfortable accommodations for family, guests, or workspace needs, while the conveniently located laundry room adds everyday functionality. The thoughtfully designed single-level layout combines comfort, efficiency, and flexibility. Additional features include a 3-car garage with garage door opener and keyless entry, quartz countertops, upgraded kitchen finishes, luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout the main living areas, stainless steel kitchen appliances, 9-foot first-floor ceilings, water softener bypass rough-in, and attractive exterior detailing that enhances curb appeal. Willow Ridge offers convenient living with easy access to Interstate 465, U.S. 52, and major roadways for a quick commute to Indianapolis. Residents enjoy shopping and dining at New Towne Square and New Palestine Plaza, along with outdoor recreation at Sugar Creek Township Park. Within the community, homeowners can enjoy a charming playground and peaceful pond view. Learn more about this exciting opportunity before it's gone!

3874 White Willow Way, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Britanny Deal. Ridgeline Realty, LLC

8328 Strong Way, Thorntown
$373,995
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Photos are of the same floor plan; finishes and features may vary. This Arbor home in the Westfall Place community offers the opportunity to enjoy new construction with anticipated completion in early January 2027, backed by a builder warranty and thoughtfully designed for modern living. The popular Palmetto floor plan features over 2,600 square feet in a spacious two-story layout that offers exceptional flexibility for a variety of lifestyles. The open-concept main level seamlessly connects the kitchen, dining area, and great room, creating an inviting space for everyday living and entertaining. A dedicated den and separate study provide valuable flexibility for home offices, playrooms, hobby spaces, or additional living areas, while the kitchen features a center island and overlooks the main gathering spaces to keep everyone connected. Upstairs, the private primary suite serves as a relaxing retreat with a spacious walk-in closet and en-suite bath featuring a double-bowl vanity and 60-inch shower with semi-frameless glass enclosure. Three additional bedrooms, a full hall bath with double-bowl vanity, conveniently located laundry room, and versatile loft provide flexible space for family and guests. Additional features include a garage side extension, quartz countertops throughout, upgraded kitchen finishes, vinyl plank flooring throughout the main living areas, a 16' x 12' patio, 9-foot first-floor ceilings, garage door opener with keyless entry, water softener bypass rough-in, and attractive exterior detailing that enhances curb appeal. Westfall Place offers peaceful small-town living with amenities including scenic pond views, walking trails, open common areas, a picnic shelter, and a playground. Residents enjoy convenient access to local shops, dining, community events, and nearby recreational trails, perfect for outdoor activities. Located near IN-47 with easy connections to nearby cities and commuter routes. Learn more about this exciting opportunity today!

8328 Strong Way, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Britanny Deal. Ridgeline Realty, LLC

5148 W Tumbleweed Court, New Palestine
$549,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to this beautifully updated home in the sought-after Countryside neighborhood! Situated on a desirable cul-de-sac lot, this home offers thoughtful updates, spacious living areas, abundant storage, and an incredible backyard retreat. With improvements throughout, this home is truly move-in ready! The stunning kitchen, updated in July 2024, features beautiful Limpus cabinetry, waterfall countertops, a stainless-steel farmhouse sink, appliance cabinet, and updated lighting. The refrigerator and dishwasher were also replaced in 2024. Fresh paint throughout and carpet replaced in 2021 add to its well-maintained appeal. The spacious primary suite features vaulted ceilings and a beautifully appointed ensuite with a walk-in shower, soaking tub, and dual vanity. Additional updates include a refreshed half bath in 2024 and LVP flooring installed downstairs in 2024. You'll also appreciate the convenient laundry chute, oversized closets, and abundant storage. Step outside to your own backyard oasis! Enjoy the fiberglass swimming pool installed in 2021, complete with a salt cell system and NEW pool heater in 2026. Relax poolside, practice your short game on the putting green, or watch the kids enjoy the playset. Additional storage units provide room for all your outdoor essentials. The three-car garage offers plenty of space for vehicles, hobbies, and additional storage. Countryside residents enjoy neighborhood amenities including a private park, pickleball courts, and tennis courts. All within the highly desired New Palestine Community School District! Beautiful updates, exceptional outdoor living, and a desirable location make this home a must-see!

5148 W Tumbleweed Court, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Missy Ackerman. F.C. Tucker Company

129 Yorkshire Boulevard E, Indianapolis
$419,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
You'll want to see this beautifully maintained and thoughtfully updated custom two-story home. The home offers 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and 2,597 square feet in the New Palestine school district. Rich hardwood floors, detailed wood trim, crown molding and wainscoting showcase the quality craftsmanship throughout. The inviting living room features a fireplace flanked by custom built-in bookcases, while the formal dining room and eat-in kitchen provide wonderful spaces for everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen features classic cabinetry, granite countertops, tile backsplash, and stainless steel appliances, with a window overlooking the backyard. The spacious primary suite offers a wood-inset tray ceiling, custom walk-in closet, and spa-inspired bath with leaded-glass privacy windows, whirlpool tub, and fully tiled shower with multiple showerheads. Additional highlights include a hall bath with dual sinks and granite countertops, a large laundry room with service sink and backyard access, and a three-car tandem garage. Enjoy outdoor living on the screened-in porch, paver patio, and pergola, along with a welcoming front porch. An impressive list of updates includes a new roof (2022); high-efficiency HVAC, water heater, water softener, sump pumps, chimney cap, and fresh interior paint (2023); plus a new garbage disposal and 30-cu.-ft. stainless refrigerator (2024). Classic character, thoughtful details, and important updates make this home a wonderful place to call home!

129 Yorkshire Boulevard E, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Lynn Fields. Home Bound Real Estate LLC

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative as distributed by MLS GRID.


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!