Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

Welcome to Sugar Creek, Indiana – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Midwest! Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Sugar Creek offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and modern convenience. With lush green parks, scenic walking trails, and a vibrant local culture, it's no wonder that families and individuals alike are drawn to this serene locale.

Sugar Creek is ideally situated just a short drive from larger urban centers, providing residents with easy access to shopping, dining, and entertainment while still enjoying the tranquility of suburban life. The area's rich history and strong sense of community make it a wonderful place to call home. Whether you’re looking to enjoy a peaceful afternoon at the local farmers market or take part in community events, there’s always something happening in Sugar Creek!

If you're in the market for a new home, you're in luck! Sugar Creek boasts a variety of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. From charming single-family houses with spacious yards to modern townhomes, there’s something for everyone. Many homes feature beautiful architectural details, updated amenities, and are located within friendly neighborhoods, perfect for raising a family or enjoying a peaceful retirement.

With its welcoming atmosphere and beautiful surroundings, Sugar Creek is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Explore the homes for sale today and discover the perfect spot for you and your loved ones in this enchanting Indiana community!

Newest Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

5538 W 300 S, New Palestine
$1
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
INVESTORS, FLIPPERS, HANDYMEN & DREAMERS: THIS IS THE ONE YOU'VE BEEN WAITING FOR! Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of New Palestine history. This classic 1900s farmhouse sits on a generous .766-acre corner lot surrounded by mature trees, with room to spread out, play, garden, and build the life you've imagined. Located in the sought-after New Palestine school district, this is the kind of location buyers and renters look for. Inside, you'll find 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, a dining room perfect for gatherings, and a versatile office for working from home or hobby space. The 2-car garage adds even more room for vehicles, tools, and projects. This home has GOOD BONES and is ready for your vision. Update it, restore it, flip it, or keep it and build instant equity. The character of a century-old farmhouse combined with the potential of an acre-sized lot is hard to find! This property will be offered at a MULTI-PARCEL AUCTION on 10/28 at 12:00 noon, along with the home at 5552 W 300 S, New Palestine. Buy one or buy both. Investors, this is your chance to scoop up two properties in one event! PREVIEW DATES: 10/17 from 1:00-3:00 PM and 10/21 from 4:00-6:00 PM. Come see the potential for yourself. Opportunities like this don't come around often, and they don't last!

5538 W 300 S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Huber Auction & Real Estate Group.

5552 W 300 S, New Palestine
$1
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
ONE-OF-A-KIND BARN HOME | LIVE & ONLINE AUCTION | NEW PALESTINE, INDIANA Step inside a true architectural original. This 3-story, 4-bedroom estate was built around the historic homestead barn, and the handmade beams and wooden pin joinery of the old barn are proudly displayed throughout. Soaring ceilings, sweeping curved staircases, and warm hardwood details make an unforgettable first impression. The great room is the heart of the home, featuring a grand stone fireplace, exposed timber beams, and a sparkling crystal chandelier, with open balconies overlooking the living space below. Rich hardwood staircases and warm wood railings flow through all three levels. Also enjoy an office, a bonus room, an eat-in kitchen, and walk-in closets. THE INDOOR POOL AREA: A true showstopper. The 48'x26' pool room is filled with natural light from arched windows and features a 15'x38' in-ground pool, a sauna, and a full bath. A wooden balcony overlooks the pool from above, creating a resort-style setting for relaxing and entertaining all year long. Perfect for morning laps or evening gatherings. GUEST APARTMENT: Above the 4-car garage, a 30'x17' apartment with a full bath and efficiency kitchen is ideal for guests, in-laws, a home office, or rental income. OUTDOOR LIVING: Relax in the outdoor hot tub on the large patio, surrounded by mature trees on .78 acres. A concrete driveway provides plenty of parking and easy access to the garage. HIGHLIGHTS: 4 bedrooms | 3 stories | Original homestead barn beams and pins | Stone fireplace | Indoor pool with sauna | Apartment above garage | 4-car garage | Hot tub | Mature trees | Concrete driveway | .78 acres A truly unique opportunity. Homes with this much history, character, and resort-style amenity are rarely offered. Whether you dream of a private retreat, multi-generational living, or an entertainer's showplace, this property delivers. Bid live or online and make this remarkable barn home yours!

5552 W 300 S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Huber Auction & Real Estate Group.

6205 W 300 S Road S, New Palestine
$297,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Some homes just feel right the moment you arrive. Nestled in the charming community of New Palestine, just a short drive from Indianapolis, this sweet two-bedroom charmer sits on a generous .59-acre lot and delivers that rare combination, the unhurried feeling of small town living with easy access to everything the city offers. The newly improved 600 South corridor opens up a lovely path to the public schools and the beloved Pennsy Trail - a wonderful bonus for walkers, cyclists, and families alike. You'll love this home with its loads of updates! The kitchen is a delight, light and airy, appointed with white cabinetry, updated countertops, a wall oven, cooktop, and direct access to the deck. The dining room offers full windows overlooking the backyard with space for a desk or a cherished plant collection, a room that functions well. A warm and inviting family room offers easy access to the backyard, making indoor and outdoor living feel effortlessly connected. The primary bedroom leads to a surprisingly beautiful updated bath featuring a full tiled shower, new counter & sink, and walk-in closet. A genuine upgrade you might not expect at this price point. A two-year-old deck with wrought iron-style railings invites you to linger. And then there is the barn, a proper little red barn with white cross doors, lovingly rebuilt and expanded with a handsome covered lean-to supported by timbers that give it real presence and shelter. Honestly, it might be your most favorite thing about the property! The unfinished basement offers excellent storage and laundry hookups, with additional stackable connections available in the main level hall closet. You will not believe all the updates; too numerous to list here. Lovingly maintained and quietly waiting, with a full updates sheet available. Some houses are just houses. This one feels like home.

6205 W 300 S Road S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

4621 W Dane Court, New Palestine
$409,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to 4621 W Dane Ct, a meticulously maintained 2,152-square-foot residence where thoughtful design, modern comfort, and complete peace of mind converge. Soaring 9-foot ceilings across both levels flood the open-concept layout with natural light, creating an exceptionally airy flow from the heart of the kitchen into a cozy living room anchored by a warm fireplace. Off the main area, a climate-controlled all-season sunroom offers the perfect year-round retreat, while upstairs, the primary suite delivers a spa-like experience with its double vanity, deep soaking tub, and oversized walk-in shower. Beyond the interior, a charm-filled front porch, back patio, and a spacious 3-car attached garage provide endless versatility, all framed by community perks including a local park and playground. What truly sets this turnkey property apart is the extensive list of major high-ticket updates that ensure worry-free living for years to come. Capital improvements include a brand-new roof, new gutters, downspouts, new screened sliding door, and select replacement windows completed in 2026, alongside freshly redone trim in 2025, a high-efficiency furnace replaced in 2024, a 2021 water heater, a solar salt water softener, and freshly deep-cleaned carpets throughout. Ready for immediate enjoyment, this exceptional two-story home offers the ideal blend of community, comfort, and top-tier maintenance in one unbeatable package.

4621 W Dane Court, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

4860 W Safford Drive, New Palestine
$398,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Some homes simply give you more space. This one gives you more ways to live. With 5 bedrooms, 3.5 baths and more than 3,100 sq ft, this New Palestine home was made for life's changing seasons whether that means a growing household, welcoming family under one roof, working from home or simply having room for everyone to feel at home. A main-level bedroom and full bath offer comfortable space for guests or extended family, while the flexible front room can become the office, playroom or dining room that fits your life. The kitchen and great room are where life naturally comes together. The large island becomes the place for morning coffee, quick breakfasts, homework and conversations while dinner is being made. Quartz countertops, updated appliances, tile backsplash, generous pantry storage, crown molding, fresh paint and thoughtful updates make the home feel both welcoming and ready to enjoy. Step outside and you may find your favorite place. Thoughtful landscaping and a spacious patio create a backyard oasis for quiet mornings, summer dinners and evenings spent with family and friends. With no immediate neighbor behind or beside the home and open common space beyond, there's a wonderful sense of openness that's hard to appreciate until you see it. Upstairs, everyone has room to spread out with a spacious loft, 4 generously sized bedrooms, large closets and the convenience of an upstairs laundry room. The primary suite offers a comfortable place to unwind, complete with double vanities and a walk-in closet with custom shelving. Copperstone adds even more to everyday life with sidewalks, a community pool and playground. It's a home with room to gather, room to grow and room for whatever comes next.

4860 W Safford Drive, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

255 Holly Lane, Greenfield
$329,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
The Aria II is a thoughtfully designed 1,601-square-foot single-story ranch home that masterfully blends modern open-concept living with functional private spaces. The heart of the home is a bright, spacious great room that flows seamlessly into the dining area and kitchen. Perfect for entertaining, the kitchen features a large counter-height island with casual bar seating, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a walk-in pantry. Designed with a popular split-bedroom layout, the Aria II prioritizes privacy. The luxurious primary suite is tucked away at the rear of the home, offering a quiet sanctuary complete with a generous walk-in closet and an ensuite bathroom with a double-sink vanity. On the opposite side of the home, two additional bedrooms share a second full bathroom, making them ideal for kids, guests, or a home office. Large windows throughout fill the entire home with natural light. Practical features include a dedicated laundry room positioned near the attached two-car garage for a smooth daily transition. Outdoor living is highlighted by a covered rear porch, extending your usable space into the backyard for dining and relaxation. Complete with smart home technology, this efficient layout beautifully caters to a wide range of lifestyles. Photos are representative of the plan and may vary.

255 Holly Lane, Greenfield

Listing courtesy of DRH Realty of Indiana, LLC.

7792 Magnolia Street, New Palestine
$464,900
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
D.R. Horton introduces the Dayton at Fields at Sugar Creek, a masterpiece of size and style spanning an impressive 3,388 square feet. This 5-bedroom home perfectly balances open-concept living with functional, upscale design. The main level features a bright, expansive great room that flows into a casual dining area and a well-appointed kitchen. Designed for home chefs, the kitchen boasts a large center island, abundant cabinet space, and a generous walk-in pantry. This level also includes a versatile flex room-ideal for a home office or playroom-and a spacious main-floor bedroom with an ensuite bath, perfect for guests or multi-generational living. Upstairs, the luxurious primary suite offers a quiet retreat with a vast walk-in closet and an elegant bathroom featuring a dual-sink vanity, deluxe shower, and private water closet. A sizable open loft overlooks the secondary bedrooms. The upper level is rounded out by a convenient laundry room and a shared hall bath equipped with a dual-sink vanity and a separate commode and shower area. Every home includes integrated smart home technology to keep you seamlessly connected. Photos are representative of the plan and may vary as built.

7792 Magnolia Street, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of DRH Realty of Indiana, LLC.

3820 N SR 75, Thorntown
$850,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Welcome home to this gorgeous property nestled on two beautiful acres in Thorntown, Indiana. An inviting front porch and striking double doors set a welcoming tone from the moment you arrive. Inside, a spacious family room anchored by a stunning fireplace flows seamlessly into the heart of the home. The updated kitchen is an entertainer's dream, featuring a large central island, stainless steel appliances, abundant workspace, and a fabulous dining area ready for a long table and memorable meals. Step right outside the kitchen to enjoy a gorgeous patio, complete with plenty of space to sit and relax, overlooking the fully fenced backyard. When it's time to unwind, the beautifully updated primary suite serves as a relaxing retreat, boasting double sinks and separate shower. A dedicated home office overlooks the sprawling grounds, making remote work a pleasure. Downstairs, the finished basement spans the home's entire footprint, providing incredible additional living space. With an entertaining area, home gym, extra bedroom, and ample storage, the lower level offers the ultimate area of flexibility. The expansive basement opens directly out to a second, private patio space perfectly designed for outdoor entertaining and unwinding in the hot tub. Outside, the picturesque two-acre setting gives you limitless room to play, entertain, and simply enjoy the peace and privacy of your own slice of Indiana.

3820 N SR 75, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

6349 W Buckskin Court, New Palestine
$315,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Room to spread out, settle in, and enjoy more space inside and out at 6349 W Buckskin Ct in New Palestine. Situated on just over half an acre, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offers 1,822 square feet of comfortable single-level living with a layout built for everyday functionality. Inside, the home offers generous living spaces with plenty of flexibility for relaxing, gathering, working from home, or creating a space that fits your lifestyle. Three bedrooms provide versatility for sleeping, guests, hobbies, or a dedicated home office, while two full bathrooms keep the floor plan practical and convenient. Outside is where the possibilities really expand. The more than half-acre lot provides plenty of room for outdoor entertaining, gardening, recreation, or simply enjoying a backyard with breathing room. Whether your vision includes evenings around a fire pit, weekend cookouts, or creating your own outdoor retreat, there's space to make it happen. With its ranch-style layout, spacious lot, and New Palestine location, 6349 W Buckskin Ct offers the combination of indoor comfort and outdoor space that's becoming increasingly difficult to find.

6349 W Buckskin Court, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Ever Real Estate, LLC.

219 Springfield Crossing, Greenfield
$295,540
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to the Greensboro by D.R. Horton, America's Builder, an exceptional quick move-in home nestled in Greenfield, IN. Designed with an impeccable balance of style and functionality, this two-story layout features 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and a versatile floor plan tailored for modern living. Step through the welcoming foyer to discover a flexible downstairs den, perfect for a quiet home office. The main floor opens into an expansive great room that flows seamlessly into the dining area and a chef-inspired kitchen, creating an inviting environment for hosting guests or relaxing. The stunning kitchen boasts ample cabinet storage, premium quartz countertops, a convenient breakfast bar, and a walk-in pantry. Upstairs, a generous loft offers a perfect space for a secondary living zone, media room, or playroom. The peaceful primary suite serves as your private retreat, featuring an oversized walk-in closet and a spa-like ensuite bathroom complete with a double vanity sink, beautifully tiled shower, dedicated linen storage, and a private commode. Enjoy outdoor living on the open back patio, complemented by a sleek rear-load garage. Additionally, every D.R. Horton home comes fully equipped with America's Smart Home technology-including a video doorbell, Honeywell thermostat, smart door lock, and a Deako lighting package. Photos are representative of plan and may vary as built.

219 Springfield Crossing, Greenfield

Listing courtesy of DRH Realty of Indiana, LLC.

3394 S Bennett Drive, New Palestine
$460,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Experience refined living at 3394 S Bennett Drive. Built in 2013, this attractive single-family residence, spanning 2508 square feet, is in great condition and offers a harmonious blend of comfort and sophisticated design. The front door entry contains a nice foyer and a bright office with custom made double doors installed in 2023. The heart of this home is undoubtedly its kitchen, a culinary haven featuring a double oven, elegant granite counters, and a convenient island, perfect for both everyday meals and entertaining. The kitchen appliances were all updated in 2019 and a new garbage disposal was installed in 2024. The living room provides a welcoming atmosphere, centered around a cozy fireplace, ideal for gathering and relaxation. The primary bathroom has a nice double vanity with a nice soaker tub offering both style and practicality. Both full bathroom floors were replaced in 2022. Beyond the interior, the property extends its living spaces outdoors with a dedicated outdoor living area to include a new patio canopy installed in 2025. A private heated pool was installed in 2023 with an automatic pool covering. New landscaping includes privacy trees and lights installed in 2026. The 3-car garage has excellent shelving and an extra enclosed space for storage. The entire home features wood blinds and new carpet installed in May of 2026. All floors downstairs have been updated and the cabinets have been refreshed and new hardware added. This property presents a rare opportunity to embrace a lifestyle of comfort and elegance.

3394 S Bennett Drive, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Capital T Realty.

5311 W 300 S, New Palestine
$282,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Set on 0.62 acres in New Palestine, this well-maintained brick ranch offers the space, privacy, and single-level living buyers are looking for. With 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and 1,577 square feet, the home features a spacious living room anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, an eat-in kitchen with breakfast bar, and a welcoming foyer. The primary suite includes a walk-in closet and private bath with a separate tub and shower, while two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. Outside, enjoy a large fully fenced backyard with plenty of room to entertain, garden, play, or simply relax beneath the mature trees. A mini barn adds convenient extra storage, and the attached finished 2-car garage provides even more functionality. With no HOA and more than half an acre, there is room to spread out without giving up convenient access to New Palestine and the Southern Hancock County school system. Whether you're drawn to the classic brick exterior, generous yard, cozy fireplace, or easy ranch-style floor plan, this property offers a comfortable place to call home with space both inside and out.

5311 W 300 S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Mark Dietel Realty, LLC.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative