Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$50,000
Escape the ordinary and build your custom retreat on this premium, wooded lot in the highly desirable Heritage Lake community! Encompassed by majestic mature trees that offer instant privacy and a serene, nestled-in-nature feel, this beautiful plot provides the ultimate flexible canvas for whatever you can dream up-whether that's a sprawling craftsman ranch, a modern lake chalet, or a cozy weekend getaway. Here, you aren't just buying a piece of land; you're investing in the coveted Heritage Lake lifestyle, complete with boating, fishing, beaches, and a vibrant community atmosphere. Don't settle for a cookie-cutter subdivision when you can keep the trees you love, clear the rest, and design your absolute dream home from the ground up!

338 Lincoln Hill, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of @properties. Selling Office: Harcourt Real Estate Team.

$48,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to the Van Bibber Lake community! This charming 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom home offers easy, low-maintenance living in a peaceful lake setting. While not waterfront, you'll still enjoy all the benefits of being part of the Van Bibber Lake community - including lake access and neighborhood amenities. This property is perfect as a weekend retreat, cozy tiny home, or an ideal retirement downsizing option. The efficient layout makes great use of space while still feeling comfortable and inviting. The home features newer HVAC with updated AC and heating for year-round comfort and efficiency. All appliances are included and will remain with the home, making this property truly move-in ready. Enjoy affordable living with a relaxing lake-life atmosphere just a short drive from town. Whether you're looking to simplify, invest, or escape for the weekends, this one is worth a look!

6116 Van Bibber Lake Estate, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Wolfpack Realty. Selling Office: Greene Realty, LLC.

$47,000
Extra-Large Heritage Lake Lot with Walkout Potential & Wooded Views. This rare oversized lot at Heritage Lake offers the perfect blend of privacy, convenience, and natural beauty. Unlike most lots, this property gives you extra space, with the top portion already cleared and ready for your dream home-perfect for a walkout basement design.The rear of the property backs to wooded conservation land, creating a private backdrop filled with trees, wildlife, and natural beauty. Imagine mornings with coffee as the sunrise brightens your future front porch, then evenings winding down with peaceful wooded views out back. For convenience, you're just a short walk to Sahm's Restaurant at the marina, where you can grab coffee, cocktails, or a great meal while enjoying the lakeside atmosphere. Even better-you'll be steps from your future boat slip. This is a rare opportunity to build in a prime location with more land, more privacy, and more possibilities than most lots at Heritage Lake.

300 Mill Springs Court, Fillmore

Listing courtesy of The Stewart Home Group. Selling Office: Wright, REALTORS®.

$46,000
RARE OPPORTUNITY! .27-acre lot in desirable Gettysburg backing up to peaceful pasture & farm fields with no homes behind you for added privacy & open views. Improvements already completed by the Sellers include culvert installed, gravel driveway added and some trees cleared to give you a great head start on building. Very few lots remain at Heritage Lake with this kind of privacy and natural setting. Don't miss your chance to secure one of the last lots available like this!

645 Gettysburg, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Greene Realty, LLC.

$46,000
HARD TO FIND over-sized lot in the desirable Heritage Lake community! With a .79 acre lot, you can build the home of your dreams AND still have plenty of yard. Both lots on either side are vacant and provide even more privacy. Enjoy all of the amenities the lake has to offer such as the pool, beaches, playgrounds, clubhouse and MORE! Don't miss out on this rare find!

285 Jefferson Valley, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Greene Realty, LLC.

$44,000
Build your dream home and start enjoying the Heritage Lake lifestyle! This beautiful vacant lot offers an incredible opportunity to create the home you've always wanted in a community where there is something for everyone. Heritage Lake offers an abundance of recreational amenities right outside your door, including boating, fishing, swimming, pickleball, and beautiful lake views and nature. Don't miss your opportunity to own a piece of Heritage Lake and enjoy the relaxed, fun-filled lifestyle this sought-after community has to offer. Bring your building plans and start making your lake-life dreams a reality.

45 Jefferson, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Greene Realty, LLC.

$43,500
Welcome to 36 Lincoln Hills, an exceptional .48-acre homesite nestled within the sought-after Heritage Lake community-where everyday living feels like a vacation. This nearly half-acre lot offers the perfect canvas to design and build your custom home, surrounded by mature trees, natural beauty, and the peaceful charm of lake living. Whether you envision a modern retreat or a timeless family home, this property provides the space and setting to bring your vision to life. Life at Heritage Lake is more than just a location-it's a lifestyle. Enjoy private lake access, perfect for boating, fishing, kayaking, and sunset cruises. Spend your summers relaxing on the water, hosting lakeside gatherings, or exploring the scenic surroundings. The community also features parks, walking trails, and recreational amenities, creating an ideal environment for both relaxation and activity. Opportunities to secure a premium homesite in a lake community like this are increasingly rare. Don't miss your chance to build not just a home-but a lifestyle.

36 Lincoln Hills, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Ever Real Estate, LLC. Selling Office: RE/MAX Cornerstone.

$42,500
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Waterfront Opportunity with Dock & Water Access! This clean 1-bedroom, 1-bath home offers a great opportunity to enjoy waterfront living while adding your own personal touches. The home is well cared for and very clean, but does need some updating. With a dock and direct water access, you can enjoy relaxing by the water, fishing, boating, or simply taking in the peaceful surroundings. Whether you're looking for a weekend getaway, a year-round home, or an investment property, this property offers plenty of potential. Bring your vision and make this waterfront retreat your own! Ceiling is stained from previous roof leaks, Roof was replaced but unsure on year. Roof has no current leaks. Carpet has been removed from bedroom. Selling property AS-IS

5014 Van Bibber Lake Estates, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Wolfpack Realty. Selling Office: Wolfpack Realty.

$42,000

2 Victory Hills, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Greene Realty, LLC.

$39,900
What a great opportunity to build a legacy of lake life for your family! This gorgeous buildable lot backs up to the Nature Preserve assuring privacy with lush forest and creek views. Take advantage of all that property ownership offers including a pristine 320-acre private recreational lake with boating, fishing, skiing, tubing and beaches. Also available are pickleball and tennis courts, a swimming pool, splash pool, water aerobics, playgrounds, summer concerts series, concert pavilion, many clubs, a clubhouse and activity center. Sahm's Haven Marina restaurant offers delicious food and libations and a place to meet up with friends and neighbors.

228 Victory Hill, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indpls Metro N. Selling Office: Keller Williams Indpls Metro N.

$39,000
Lot 422 in Mill Springs listed and pended.

422 Mill Springs, Fillmore

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Greene Realty, LLC.

$38,000
Long live LAKE LIFE! Have the best of both worlds - enjoy the fun of Heritage Lake and come home to your serene, wooded lot with sunset pond views on a cul-de-sac. Bring your builder to design your dream home, use as storage for up to 3 open trailers or just enjoy owning this beautiful investment and take advantage of all the amenities: marina & lake access, beaches, tennis, pickle ball, pool, playgrounds, & dining at Sahm's Haven Restaurant.

190 Lincoln Hills, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: The Stewart Home Group.

$37,500
Tucked within the sought-after Heritage Lake community, this wooded lot offers a rare opportunity to create the lifestyle you've been dreaming of! Whether your vision includes building a custom home surrounded by nature or simply securing a low-maintenance property for private lake access, this parcel delivers flexibility and privacy in equal measure. Mature trees provide a peaceful, secluded setting while still allowing easy access to the neighborhood's expansive lake-perfect for boating, fishing, or quiet evenings by the water. Located in Coatesville and served by North Putnam Schools, this lot combines natural beauty with the benefits of an established lake community. Bring your builder, bring your plans, or simply bring your love for lake living-this Heritage Lake lot is ready for its next owner!

518 Mill, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of @properties. Selling Office: Wright, REALTORS®.

$35,000
Have the best of both worlds-enjoy the fun of Heritage Lake and come home to your serene wooded lot. Bring your builder to design your dream home. Take advantage of all the amenities: marina & lake life access, beaches, tennis, pickle ball, pool , playgrounds & dining at Sahm'S Restaurant

245 Victory Hill, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Priority Realty Group. Selling Office: Priority Realty Group.

$35,000
Build your dream home on this .32-acre wooded lot on your own cul-de-sac. As a member of our community you can enjoy boating, fishing, watersports, 3 beaches & playgrounds, swimming pool and a splash pool at the clubhouse, summer concerts, festivals and more.

136 Jefferson, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Priority Realty Group. Selling Office: Priority Realty Group.

$35,000
This attractive wooded lot, featuring mature trees, is situated within the Heritage Lake Community. The location provides an excellent opportunity to construct a custom residence in a tranquil setting, with access to a wide range of amenities such as a 320-private lake. The pristine lake is well-suited for recreational activities including boating, fishing, skiing, tubing, and hosting gatherings with family and friends. Additional community features include a large pool with splash pad, parks, clubhouse, activities center, beach, picnic shelters, tennis and pickleball courts, trails and a marina. Resident may also enjoy concerts, organized events, or leisure time at the beach. Sahm's Haven restaurant is conveniently located at the marina for lunch or dinner. All lake facilities and amenities are exclusively available to property owners.

553 Mill, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Priority Realty Group. Selling Office: Priority Realty Group.

$32,000
AMAZING OPPORTUNITY to build your dream home or just have lake rights in the desirable, Heritage Lake community! This single, low maintenance lot is located on a low traffic side street and is not far from the Heritage Lake Clubhouse. Enjoy all of the amenities that the community has to offer such as the pool, beaches, playgrounds, campground and more! Don't miss out on this one, schedule your showing today!

500 Jefferson Valley, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Greene Realty, LLC.

$32,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Lake community living at its best! This 2 bedroom, 1 bath home with a bonus room and golf cart garage offers the perfect retreat. Spend your days on the water, then come back and relax in your very own camping-style getaway. With some TLC, you can make this property truly your own!

6077 Van Bibber Lake, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Wolfpack Realty. Selling Office: Wolfpack Realty.

$29,500
Build your dream home on this beautiful .32-acre lot, perfectly situated in the sought-after Heritage Lake community. Boasting serene water views, this property offers a prime location just steps from the vibrant community center and pool-where live concerts and events bring the neighborhood to life all summer long! Property Highlights: Spectacular Water Views: Enjoy the peaceful scenery right from your future home. Prime Location: Just around the corner from the community center, pool, and summer entertainment hub. Buildable Lot: Perfect for your custom home or a vacation retreat. Exclusive Community Amenities: Heritage Lake offers a private lake for boating and fishing, a marina, clubhouse, swimming pool, tennis courts, pickleball, multiple parks and year-round activities. Ready for Development: Convenient access to utilities for easy building. This lot combines the best of tranquil lakeside living with the excitement of a community that offers something for everyone. Don't miss this chance to create your perfect home at Heritage Lake-schedule a visit today!

48 Jefferson Valley, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of The Stewart Home Group. Selling Office: The Stewart Home Group.

$28,500
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to lake living at Van Bibber Lake! This 1-bedroom, 1-bath home (Camper) offers an affordable opportunity for a weekend retreat, seasonal getaway, or year-round residence. The property features a tankless water heater, mini-split heating and cooling system, and washer/dryer hookups for added convenience. The efficient layout maximizes space while keeping maintenance to a minimum. Enjoy all that the Van Bibber Lake community has to offer, including boating, fishing, and relaxing lake life. Whether you're looking for a personal retreat or a low-maintenance home, this property is ready for you to make it your own. Comes with new oven/stove, microwave and refrigerator.

4049 Van Bibber Lake Estate, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Wolfpack Realty. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Advantage, REALTOR.

$25,000

310 W Vine, Bainbridge

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Greene Realty, LLC.

$25,000
Build your dream home in the highly desirable Heritage Lake community on this hard-to-find oversized 0.61-acre vacant lot! This unique property features a scenic creek running through the lot, creating a beautiful natural setting while still providing ample space to build. An existing easement does not prevent construction on either side of the property, leaving plenty of room for your future home and yard. Enjoy added privacy with no homes currently located on the adjacent lots and only one existing home on the cul-de-sac. Whether you're looking to build now or simply enjoy all that Heritage Lake has to offer, this property is an excellent opportunity. Heritage Lake features a private 320-acre lake perfect for boating, fishing, swimming, and waterfront recreation. Residents also enjoy community beaches, a swimming pool, and a variety of year-round community activities. Don't miss your chance to own one of the larger lots available in this sought-after lake community!

20 Victory, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Capstone Realty Group, Inc. Selling Office: Capstone Realty Group, Inc.

$23,000
Here's a great opportunity to build your dream home and live the Heritage Lake Life. Tailor your layout. You can design the floor plan to suit your lifestyle, whether you need a home office, a larger kitchen, larger garage or a specific number of bedrooms. Incorporate unique architectural details and features that reflect your style, such as custom cabinetry, high ceilings, or a specific type of staircase. Enjoy picturesque views of the forest and ravine, with seasonal changes adding to the charm and aesthetics of your home. The natural barrier created by trees and the ravine offers a secluded environment, shielding your home from neighbors. The wooded area and ravine can attract a variety of wildlife, offering opportunities for birdwatching and observing nature. Trees provide shade, helping to keep your home cooler during hot summer months and reducing energy costs. As a member of our community, you can enjoy boating, fishing, watersports, 3 beaches & playgrounds, swimming pool & splash pad at the clubhouse, summer concerts, festivals and more. Start living the lake life today!

209 Victory, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX At The Crossing. Selling Office: RE/MAX Centerstone.

$18,000
**Secluded .40-Acre Paradise Overlooking Big Walnut Creek - Endless Nature Access in Putnam County!** Escape to your own private slice of Indiana's natural beauty with this stunning **0.40-acre parcel** located at 0000 800 N, Bainbridge, IN 46105, in picturesque Putnam County. Nestled off the scenic Big Walnut Creek and directly surrounded by the expansive **Big Walnut Natural Area** - a 2,600-acre protected preserve managed by The Nature Conservancy (TNC) and Indiana DNR - this property offers breathtaking views overlooking the pristine waters of Big Walnut Creek, one of Indiana's highest-quality streams. A portion of the preserve lies **directly across the road**, providing seamless, endless access to some of the region's finest hiking and outdoor recreation. Explore multiple well-maintained trailheads right nearby, including the **Tall Timbers Trail** (a moderate 1.9-2.8 mile loop through towering old-growth woodlands with dramatic ravines and creek overlooks), **Hemlock Ridge Trail** (featuring rare eastern hemlock stands and diverse forest communities), **Doyle Trail**, and **Rayfield Trail**. These trails wind through rolling hills, steep ravines, floodplain forests, and upland ridges, offering opportunities for birdwatching, wildflower viewing, and peaceful immersion in nature year-round. This parcel is ideal for **recreational use**, making it a perfect spot to camp, relax, and enjoy unlimited access to hiking, wildlife observation, and the tranquility of protected lands. (Note: Hunting is not permitted in the preserve, though limited deer hunting permits may be available through TNC on select properties - contact TNC for details.) Enjoy incredibly **low annual taxes of just $78**, adding to the appeal of this affordable nature retreat. Conveniently located near the charming town of Bainbridge, with easy access to Greencastle (home to DePauw University), historic covered bridges, and other Putnam County attractions.

800 North, Bainbridge

Listing courtesy of Mossy Oak Properties. Selling Office: .

$15,500
AFFORDABLE lot at Van Bibber Lake! Make this lot your own by either fixing up the existing mobile home or putting in something new. Enjoy everything this lake community has to offer such as boating, fishing, etc. Just in time for summer! Don't miss out on this one, schedule your showing today!

3117 Van Bibber Lake Estates, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Greene Realty, LLC.

$13,000
Vacant buildable lot! Looking to build a new home at Heritage Lake or just enjoy access to the lake? Look no further. The 320 acre private lake offers boating, swimming, fishing, beaches, community pool, and community activities.

264 Victory Hill, Coatesville

Listing courtesy of Wright, REALTORS®. Selling Office: Wright, REALTORS®.

$12,000
Affordable, vacant lot in the Van Bibber Lake community! Park your camper, or add a smaller home to the lot and enjoy everything the community has to offer! Boating, fishing, etc. Just in time for summer! Don't miss out on this one, schedule your showing today!

5108 Van Bibber Lake Estate, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Greene Realty, LLC.

$11,000
40x50 lot located in the Van Bibber Lake community-perfect for summer fun! This property includes a shed and a concrete pad, making it ideal for parking a camper or enjoying weekends at the lake. A water pit is already on site (approximately $4,200 value), offering great savings for the next owner. Bring your camper, park your boat, and enjoy everything lake life has to offer. This community allows year-round living, and the lot offers the potential to build a small home if desired. An affordable opportunity to own your own slice at Van Bibber!

5155 Van Bibber Lake Estate, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Wolfpack Realty. Selling Office: Wolfpack Realty.

$8,500
Bring your vision to life with this great lot in the desirable Van Bibber Lake community! This ready-to-enjoy property features paved parking, a freestanding shelter, and a large mature shade tree, creating the perfect setup for weekend getaways or future plans. Whether you're looking for a place to park your camper, relax with family and friends, or invest in lake community living, this lot offers endless possibilities. Enjoy all the amenities and recreation that Van Bibber Lake has to offer, including boating, fishing, swimming, and a welcoming community atmosphere.

5170 Van Bibber Lake Estates, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Wolfpack Realty. Selling Office: Wolfpack Realty.

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative